{
  "title": "Subscription billing cost worksheet",
  "description": "Compare billing fees on a smaller month and a larger month, with payment processing and credits shown separately.",
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "stripe-billing",
      "label": "Stripe Billing pricing",
      "url": "https://stripe.com/billing/pricing"
    },
    {
      "id": "stripe-volume",
      "label": "Stripe explanation of Billing volume, July 2024 plan changes",
      "url": "https://support.stripe.com/questions/july-2024-changes-to-stripe-billing"
    },
    {
      "id": "stripe-credits",
      "label": "Stripe Billing credits pricing",
      "url": "https://support.stripe.com/questions/billing-credits-pricing-understanding-credit-funding-and-applications"
    },
    {
      "id": "chargebee-pricing",
      "label": "Chargebee pricing",
      "url": "https://www.chargebee.com/pricing/"
    },
    {
      "id": "recurly-pricing",
      "label": "Recurly pricing",
      "url": "https://recurly.com/pricing/"
    },
    {
      "id": "lago-pricing",
      "label": "Lago pricing",
      "url": "https://getlago.com/pricing"
    },
    {
      "id": "metronome-pricing",
      "label": "Metronome pricing",
      "url": "https://metronome.com/pricing"
    },
    {
      "id": "orb-pricing",
      "label": "Orb pricing",
      "url": "https://www.withorb.com/pricing"
    },
    {
      "id": "paddle-pricing",
      "label": "Paddle pricing",
      "url": "https://www.paddle.com/pricing"
    },
    {
      "id": "zoho-billing",
      "label": "Zoho Billing pricing",
      "url": "https://www.zoho.com/billing/pricing/"
    },
    {
      "id": "maxio-pricing",
      "label": "Maxio pricing",
      "url": "https://www.maxio.com/pricing"
    },
    {
      "id": "m3ter-pricing",
      "label": "m3ter pricing",
      "url": "https://www.m3ter.com/pricing/"
    },
    {
      "id": "zuora-datasheet",
      "label": "Zuora billing package FAQ",
      "url": "https://www.zuora.com/frequently-asked-questions/"
    }
  ],
  "sections": [
    {
      "id": "workload-eighty-thousand",
      "heading": "Smaller subscription month",
      "intro": "Inputs: $80,000 of subscription invoices in the month, 400 successful charges that add up to $80,000, 100,000 usage events, and $4,000 of credit notes. The credit notes are not subtracted. There are no one-off invoices. The ACH line assumes 400 equal charges of $200. Card processing uses the published US domestic card rate and is not a blended effective rate.",
      "headers": [
        "Structure",
        "Platform fee",
        "Event fee",
        "Processing, separate",
        "Platform total",
        "Notes"
      ],
      "rows": [
        [
          "Stripe Billing, pay as you go",
          "$560",
          "$0. 100,000 events are inside 100 million.",
          "$2,440 on cards, or $640 on the equal-charge ACH example",
          "$560",
          "0.7% x $80,000. The $100,000 tier is $620, which is $60 more than pay as you go at this volume. The tier's 11% saving is against 0.7% of the $100,000 cap, not against $80,000."
        ],
        [
          "Stripe platform plus cards",
          "$560",
          "$0",
          "$2,440",
          "$3,000",
          "Sum of the Billing line and the card line. It is two fees. 2.9% x $80,000 = $2,320 and 400 x $0.30 = $120."
        ],
        [
          "Stripe platform plus ACH example",
          "$560",
          "$0",
          "$640",
          "$1,200",
          "0.8% of $200 is $1.60, under the $5 cap, times 400. This replaces the card line. It is not added to it."
        ],
        [
          "Chargebee Flow, $0 + 0.80%",
          "$640",
          "$0 inside 100 million events",
          "Gateway fee. Not a Chargebee price.",
          "$640",
          "0.80% x $80,000. Above the $66,000 breakeven, so the other Flow structure is cheaper."
        ],
        [
          "Chargebee Flow, $99 + 0.65%",
          "$619",
          "$0",
          "Same gateway fee, still separate.",
          "$619",
          "$99 + 0.65% x $80,000 = $99 + $520. That is $21 less than the zero-base structure."
        ],
        [
          "Recurly Starter",
          "$609",
          "No public event fee",
          "Gateway fee, separate.",
          "$609",
          "$249 + 0.9% x ($80,000 - $40,000) = $249 + $360. All-Access is not applied. $80,000 in the month and $960,000 in the year are both under a $1 million figure, and the page does not say which period the minimum uses."
        ],
        [
          "Lago Launch, first month inside both allowances",
          "$0",
          "$0",
          "Provider fee, separate.",
          "$0",
          "The $100,000 billing allowance and the 5 million event allowance are one-time. This row is only the month before either allowance is used up. It is not the ongoing price."
        ],
        [
          "Lago Launch, after both allowances are used",
          "$560",
          "$2",
          "Provider fee, separate.",
          "$562",
          "0.7% x $80,000 = $560. 100,000 events are 0.1 million x $20 = $2."
        ],
        [
          "Metronome Starter",
          "$640",
          "$4",
          "Stripe processing extra if Stripe collects. Not included.",
          "$644",
          "0.8% x $80,000 = $640. 100,000 / 1,000 x $0.04 = $4. Do not add Stripe's 0.7% as well."
        ],
        [
          "Paddle pay as you go",
          "$4,200",
          "Included in the checkout fee",
          "Included. Do not add the Stripe card line.",
          "$4,200",
          "5% x $80,000 = $4,000 and 400 x $0.50 = $200. This buys merchant-of-record tax and buyer payment support. It is not comparable to a $560 Billing line."
        ],
        [
          "Zoho Billing Premium, annual",
          "$79",
          "No per-event charge published",
          "Not in the $79.",
          "$79",
          "Annual billed amount is 12 x $80,000 = $960,000, under the $1 million cap. Invoices are 12 x 400 = 4,800, under 100,000. The included 10 users cover a small finance team, so no user add-on is included. Monthly billing of the same plan is $100. Standard at $39 does not include subscription billing."
        ],
        [
          "Maxio Grow, default annual agreement",
          "$599",
          "Usage-based billing is listed. Confirm any metering add-on.",
          "Gateway fee, separate.",
          "$599 if the account is still inside $100,000 of monthly billings",
          "The vendor's default agreements are paid annually. It offers monthly or quarterly payment at a premium. The public Grow band covers up to $100,000 in monthly billings."
        ],
        [
          "Orb, m3ter, Zuora",
          "Not calculated",
          "Not calculated",
          "Separate where a gateway is used",
          "Quote only or not calculable",
          "Orb is $6 per credit with no public credit conversion. m3ter prints no dollars. Zuora has no public price in the catalog."
        ]
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "On platform fees alone, the closed figures for this month are Stripe pay as you go at $560, Lago at $562 after the one-time allowances, Chargebee's lower Flow structure at $619, Recurly Starter at $609, Metronome at $644, Maxio Grow at $599, and Zoho Premium at $79. Paddle is $4,200 because the fee includes processing and tax. Stripe's own card line is $2,440, so Stripe Billing plus Stripe cards is $3,000, still a different bundle from Paddle.",
        "Lago's first month at $0 is an allowance, not a list price. Using it as the comparison price against Stripe's $560 misstates the second month. Chargebee Enterprise, Recurly All-Access, Orb, m3ter, and Zuora are not given a number."
      ],
      "source_ids": [
        "stripe-billing",
        "stripe-volume",
        "chargebee-pricing",
        "recurly-pricing",
        "lago-pricing",
        "metronome-pricing",
        "paddle-pricing",
        "zoho-billing",
        "maxio-pricing",
        "orb-pricing",
        "m3ter-pricing",
        "zuora-datasheet"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "workload-four-hundred-thousand",
      "heading": "Larger subscription month",
      "intro": "Second sample: $400,000 of subscription billing volume, 2,000 successful charges that add up to $400,000, 8 million usage events, and $20,000 of credit notes. Credit notes are not subtracted. The annual billed amount used only for Zoho's published cap is 12 x $400,000 = $4.8 million. The ACH line again assumes equal charges of $200.",
      "headers": [
        "Structure",
        "Platform fee",
        "Event fee",
        "Processing, separate",
        "Platform total",
        "Notes"
      ],
      "rows": [
        [
          "Stripe Billing, pay as you go",
          "$2,800",
          "$0. 8 million events are inside 100 million.",
          "$12,200 on cards",
          "$2,800",
          "0.7% x $400,000. No annual contract."
        ],
        [
          "Stripe Billing, $100,000 tier plus 0.67%",
          "$2,630",
          "$0",
          "$12,200 on cards",
          "$2,630",
          "$620 + 0.67% x $300,000 = $620 + $2,010. One-year contract. Worse than the $250,000 tier at this volume."
        ],
        [
          "Stripe Billing, $250,000 tier plus 0.67%",
          "$2,505",
          "$0",
          "$12,200 on cards",
          "$2,505",
          "$1,500 + 0.67% x $150,000 = $1,500 + $1,005. Lowest published Stripe Billing structure for this sample. The $500,000 tier is $2,950 with no overage, which is more than both pay as you go and this tier."
        ],
        [
          "Stripe $250,000 tier plus cards",
          "$2,505",
          "$0",
          "$12,200",
          "$14,705",
          "Two fees added for a card-only collection. 2.9% x $400,000 = $11,600 and 2,000 x $0.30 = $600. ACH on 2,000 equal $200 charges would be $3,200 instead of $12,200, because $1.60 is under the $5 cap."
        ],
        [
          "Chargebee Flow, $99 + 0.65%",
          "$2,699",
          "$0 inside 100 million",
          "Gateway fee, separate.",
          "$2,699",
          "$99 + 0.65% x $400,000 = $99 + $2,600. The $0 + 0.80% structure is 0.80% x $400,000 = $3,200. The 500 million event add-on is not required at 8 million and has no public price."
        ],
        [
          "Recurly Starter",
          "$3,489",
          "No public event fee",
          "Gateway fee, separate.",
          "$3,489",
          "$249 + 0.9% x $360,000 = $249 + $3,240. All-Access stays a quote. A monthly $400,000 is under $1 million. The year's $4.8 million is over $1 million. The page does not say which comparison applies."
        ],
        [
          "Lago Launch, first month with fresh allowances",
          "$2,100",
          "$60",
          "Provider fee, separate.",
          "$2,160",
          "0.7% x ($400,000 - $100,000) = $2,100. Events are 3 million above the one-time 5 million, at $20 per million = $60. Only the first month looks like this."
        ],
        [
          "Lago Launch, after the allowances",
          "$2,800",
          "$160",
          "Provider fee, separate.",
          "$2,960",
          "0.7% x $400,000 = $2,800. 8 million events x $20 per million = $160. Scale's from 0.6% would be $2,400 a month before any volume decrease, which is already above the $12,000 a year minimum, but the contracted rate and the event price are not published. Scale is not given a total."
        ],
        [
          "Metronome Starter",
          "$3,200",
          "$320",
          "Stripe processing extra, not included.",
          "$3,520",
          "0.8% x $400,000 = $3,200. 8,000,000 / 1,000 x $0.04 = $320. Salesforce or NetSuite on the custom plan is a further quote."
        ],
        [
          "Paddle pay as you go",
          "$21,000",
          "Included",
          "Included. Do not add $12,200.",
          "$21,000",
          "5% x $400,000 = $20,000 and 2,000 x $0.50 = $1,000. High-volume custom pricing exists and is not estimated. The list fee is the merchant-of-record price, including tax remittance that the Stripe lines do not include."
        ],
        [
          "Zoho Billing Premium",
          "Published plan does not cover this volume",
          "Not reached",
          "Not reached",
          "No public price",
          "Annual billed amount of $4.8 million is over the $1 million Premium cap. Invoice count of 24,000 a year is under 100,000. The cap that fails is the billed amount. Enterprise is the path, and it has no public price. The $79 price is not the cost of this sample."
        ],
        [
          "Maxio",
          "Grow stops at $100,000 of monthly billings",
          "Not published on Scale",
          "Separate",
          "Quote",
          "This sample is above the catalog's Grow band. Scale is a quote. No dollar total."
        ],
        [
          "Orb, m3ter, Zuora",
          "Not calculated",
          "Not calculated",
          "Separate where a gateway is used",
          "Quote only or not calculable",
          "Same gap as the smaller sample. A higher volume does not create a public rate schedule that was not published."
        ]
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "The lowest closed platform fees on this sample are Stripe's $250,000 tier plus overage at $2,505, Chargebee's lower Flow structure at $2,699, and Lago Launch after the allowances at $2,960. Stripe pay as you go is $2,800. Metronome is $3,520 once events are included. Recurly Starter is $3,489. Paddle's list checkout fee is $21,000 and already includes processing. Stripe cards on the same charges are $12,200, so the Stripe tier plus cards is $14,705, still without tax remittance.",
        "Choosing the $500,000 Stripe tier because the volume sits under $500,000 would cost $2,950, which is $445 more than the $250,000 tier plus the published overage. The pricing page lists 0.67% additional volume on each tier, so the lower tier plus overage is an allowed reading. Confirm the contract lets you sit on the lower tier."
      ],
      "source_ids": [
        "stripe-billing",
        "chargebee-pricing",
        "recurly-pricing",
        "lago-pricing",
        "metronome-pricing",
        "paddle-pricing",
        "zoho-billing",
        "maxio-pricing",
        "orb-pricing",
        "m3ter-pricing",
        "zuora-datasheet"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "how-fees-split",
      "heading": "Where the card rate sits next to the platform fee",
      "intro": "Most of these products bill a percent of volume or a platform fee. Card and bank fees belong to the processor unless the vendor is the merchant of record. The samples never add a processor fee to Paddle, and they never add Stripe Billing's percent on top of Metronome or Chargebee. Credit notes in the samples are recorded and are not subtracted, because these pricing pages do not say to subtract them.",
      "headers": [
        "Vendor",
        "Software fee",
        "Events",
        "Processing",
        "What stays a quote"
      ],
      "rows": [
        [
          "Stripe Billing",
          "Pay as you go is 0.7% of Billing volume. Annual tiers, paid monthly on a 1-year contract: $620, $1,500, $2,950, and $5,750 for up to $100,000, $250,000, $500,000, and $1,000,000 a month. Additional volume on a tier is 0.67%. Above $1,000,000 is custom.",
          "Basic metered billing through the Meters API includes up to 100 million events a month. The pricing page points usage-based products past that at Metronome.",
          "Separate. The same pricing page lists 2.9% + 30 cents per successful card charge, and 0.8% per ACH Direct Debit with a $5 cap. Billing volume includes Billing transactions on and off Stripe, and excludes one-off invoices.",
          "Custom volume. A $10 custom-domain charge appears on the pricing table and is not used in the samples. Revenue recognition is a separate product and is not in the totals."
        ],
        [
          "Chargebee Billing, Flow",
          "Two published structures: $0 plus 0.80% of monthly invoicing volume, or $99 plus 0.65%. The page marks the breakeven at $66,000. The rates meet where 0.80% of volume equals $99 plus 0.65% of volume, which is $66,000.",
          "100 million usage events a month included. A higher ingest cap is a paid add-on with no dollar amount on the comparison table.",
          "Not a Chargebee percent. The page says the product plugs into 40 or more payment gateways. If the gateway is Stripe, use Stripe's processing line, not a second billing percent.",
          "Enterprise, RevRec, CPQ beyond the first 50 quotes, and several integrations marked with a dollar sign and no amount."
        ],
        [
          "Recurly Starter",
          "$249 per month plus 0.9% of billing volume. The first $40,000 of billings each month is included at no charge, so the 0.9% is applied above $40,000.",
          "No public event meter on the Starter card.",
          "Not included. Starter lists 20 or more payment gateways and 10 or more payment methods.",
          "All-Access is as low as under 1% of billing volume, billed annually, with a $1 million billing-volume minimum. The page does not say whether that minimum is monthly or annual, so it is not calculated. RevRec is as low as $850 per month and Engage as low as $1,600, both billed annually and both separate products."
        ],
        [
          "Lago Launch",
          "First $100,000 of processed billings free, one time, then 0.7%.",
          "First 5 million accepted production events free, one time, then $20 per million. The FAQ says the two allowances are separate.",
          "Lago calculates and invoices. The payment provider charges processing. Stripe processing is not a Lago fee.",
          "Scale starts at a $12,000 a year minimum and from 0.6% of volume, decreasing, with event rates in the agreement. That is not a closed price. Enterprise is custom. The open-source edition has no published billing percent. Hosting it is your cost and is not estimated here. Cloud signup is team-assisted today. The free sandbox is described as coming soon."
        ],
        [
          "Metronome Starter",
          "0.8% of billing volume.",
          "$0.04 per 1,000 ingested events. No free event allowance is printed.",
          "Native Stripe integration. Stripe processing is extra and is not added to the 0.8%. Do not also add Stripe Billing's 0.7%. Metronome is now part of Stripe. The Starter rate is still the rate on Metronome's pricing page.",
          "Custom plan for Salesforce, NetSuite, and cloud marketplace invoicing."
        ],
        [
          "Orb Business",
          "$6.00 per credit, or less with volume discounts. The discount schedule is not published.",
          "Credits are consumed by billings processed, events ingested, and other meters. The page does not say how many credits a dollar or an event uses.",
          "Stripe and Adyen integrations are included. Their processing rates are not on Orb's page.",
          "The sample total is not calculable. Enterprise is custom."
        ],
        [
          "Paddle",
          "5% + 50 cents per Checkout transaction. No monthly fee on the pay-as-you-go plan.",
          "No separate event meter on the pricing page.",
          "Included. Paddle is the merchant of record. The pricing FAQ says there is no extra charge for payments, tax compliance, migration, or payment-related buyer support. Do not add Stripe's 2.9% + 30 cents on top.",
          "Custom pricing for high volume or transactions under $10. Refund treatment of the 5% and the 50 cents is not on the pricing page, so the samples do not reverse it."
        ],
        [
          "Zoho Billing Premium",
          "$100 per organization per month, or $79 per month billed annually, for up to 10 users. Extra users are $9 or $7.50. Standard is $50 or $39 and is one-time billing only, so it is the wrong plan for subscriptions.",
          "Usage-based billing is on Premium. No per-event price is published.",
          "Not included in the plan fee. The page does not publish a card rate. A Zoho Payments credit offer is a promotion for new users, not a processing rate.",
          "Enterprise has no public price. Premium allows up to 100,000 invoices a year and annual billed amount not over $1 million. Prices exclude local taxes."
        ],
        [
          "Maxio, m3ter, Zuora",
          "Maxio lists Grow at $599 per month up to $100,000 in monthly billings. Default agreements are paid annually. Monthly and quarterly billing options carry a premium. Scale is quote-only.",
          "m3ter publishes a platform fee and allowances. Zuora asks buyers to discuss packaging with its sales team. Both need a quote.",
          "Maxio lists 20 or more gateways. Processing is separate and unpublished here.",
          "Maxio Scale, all of m3ter, and all of Zuora stay quote-only or unconfirmed. No sample total is invented for them."
        ]
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "Stripe's help article on Billing volume says the fee base is transactions that use Billing, including subscriptions and usage-based billing, whether Stripe processed the payment or not, and that one-off invoices are outside it. The samples contain only subscription invoices, so the one-off exclusion does not reduce them.",
        "Stripe's Billing credits article describes two regimes. During the public preview that began in October 2024, applied credit amounts did not count toward Billing volume. Under the general-availability rule the article dates to the first half of 2026, applied credits do count, at the Billing rate, and on a subscription plan they count against the volume entitlement. A credit note is a different object. The samples do not net credit notes off the percent. Confirm on the order form which regime the account is in before treating a credit as free of the Billing fee."
      ],
      "source_ids": [
        "stripe-billing",
        "stripe-volume",
        "stripe-credits",
        "chargebee-pricing",
        "recurly-pricing",
        "lago-pricing",
        "metronome-pricing",
        "orb-pricing",
        "paddle-pricing",
        "zoho-billing",
        "maxio-pricing",
        "m3ter-pricing",
        "zuora-datasheet"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "decision-and-migration",
      "heading": "Sandbox checks before an annual billing term",
      "intro": "Use one sandbox month of the price list you already sell. The checks below are the ones that move the totals in the two samples.",
      "headers": [
        "Check",
        "What to do in the sandbox",
        "What the public terms already say"
      ],
      "rows": [
        [
          "Split the bill into three lines",
          "Software fee, processor fee, tax and revenue recognition.",
          "Stripe prints Billing and card rates on the same page and they add. Chargebee, Recurly, Lago, Metronome, Orb, and Maxio point at a gateway. Paddle's 5% + 50 cents replaces the processor and the tax filing. Adding Stripe cards to Paddle double counts."
        ],
        [
          "Do not net credit notes until the contract says so",
          "Issue one credit note against a paid invoice and one against an open invoice. Record whether the fee base moves.",
          "These samples keep the full subscription volume. Stripe's credits article says applied Billing credits count toward volume under the general-availability rule dated to the first half of 2026. That is credits applied to invoices, not an automatic reduction for every credit note."
        ],
        [
          "Keep one-off invoices out of the Stripe Billing percent",
          "Add a single non-subscription invoice and see which product bills it.",
          "Stripe Billing volume excludes one-off invoices. Invoicing is charged separately. The samples have none, so that fee is not in the totals."
        ],
        [
          "Replay a messy month",
          "Mid-cycle upgrade, grandfathered price, failed payment, late usage event, and a duplicate event.",
          "Chargebee and Lago both meter usage. Stripe includes 100 million basic meter events in Billing. Metronome charges from the first 1,000 events at $0.04. A duplicate event is a dollar on Metronome and on Lago after the allowance, and it may also change the invoice the percent is charged on."
        ],
        [
          "Treat Lago's free amounts as opening balances",
          "Ask for the remaining free billings and free events in writing.",
          "Both are one-time. The $80,000 sample is $0 in the first month and $562 after the allowances. The $400,000 sample is $2,160 then $2,960. Scale is still a quote."
        ],
        [
          "Annual billed amount against the published cap",
          "Compare annual billed amount and invoice count with Zoho. Compare monthly billings with Maxio Grow and Recurly's $40,000 exclusion.",
          "Zoho Premium and Maxio Grow fit the stated limits in the smaller example. Recurly applies 0.9% above $40,000 each month."
        ],
        [
          "Pick the Stripe tier from the overage math",
          "Price pay as you go, the tier the volume falls inside, and the next tier down plus 0.67%.",
          "At $80,000, pay as you go beats the $620 tier. At $400,000, the $250,000 tier plus overage beats pay as you go and beats the $500,000 tier. The tiers are 1-year contracts."
        ],
        [
          "Plan the exit before the import",
          "Export subscribers, invoices, credit balances, and price history. Ask the current processor how cards move.",
          "Paddle's FAQ says there is no lock-in and the data can be migrated. Stored payment methods under a merchant of record are a separate question from a CSV of invoices. Lago Cloud access is team-assisted, so a self-serve sandbox is not the current path. Keep the old system readable through one full billing cycle."
        ]
      ],
      "paragraphs": [
        "Quote-only for these samples: Chargebee Enterprise, Recurly All-Access, Lago Scale and Enterprise, Metronome Custom, Orb's credit conversion and Enterprise plan, Maxio above $100,000 of monthly billings, Zoho Billing Enterprise, Paddle's high-volume contract, m3ter, and Zuora. None of those rows is filled with a guessed rate.",
        "The processor line uses Stripe's published US card rate and a simple ACH example. It is not an estimate of a real effective rate. International cards, currency conversion, and disputes are outside both samples. So is sales tax on the software invoice itself. Zoho's page says its prices exclude local taxes."
      ],
      "source_ids": [
        "stripe-billing",
        "stripe-volume",
        "stripe-credits",
        "chargebee-pricing",
        "recurly-pricing",
        "lago-pricing",
        "metronome-pricing",
        "orb-pricing",
        "paddle-pricing",
        "zoho-billing",
        "maxio-pricing",
        "m3ter-pricing",
        "zuora-datasheet"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
