Accounts payable exception and cost worksheet
A modeled month on QuickBooks Online. The invoice does not match the receipt, and unpublished fees stay out of the totals.
An invoice that overbills the receipt
Use the same bill in every demo. A purchase order covers 10 units. The receipt covers 6. The invoice bills all 10 at $4,200. Hold the 4 units that were not received, and require the department owner to approve that vendor even when an amount rule would send it elsewhere. Pay only the accepted portion by standard ACH from a bank account, into one QuickBooks Online company. This worksheet did not open vendor accounts or run the bill.
| Step | Matched input | What the public pages support |
|---|---|---|
| Short receipt | Pay 6 received units. Hold the other 4 until a second approval. | BILL lists 2-way and 3-way matching on custom-priced Enterprise, and says the feature varies by accounting software. Corporate includes 2-way matching. Melio lists partial payments on every plan and does not list receipt matching. Ramp lists three-way match with its own purchase orders on the Procurement add-on to Plus or Enterprise. |
| Approval authority | The department owner must approve this vendor. | BILL custom approval policies start on Corporate. Team has standard policies only. Melio Core lists per-vendor, per-amount, per-user, multiple and gradual approvals. Ramp Free lists approval rules. Routing by vendor, department, accounting field or payment type is marked as a Plus addition, as are payment release approvals. |
| Accounting sync | The bill, the held amount and the payment appear in QuickBooks Online. | BILL automatic two-way sync starts on Team. Essentials is CSV import and export. Melio QuickBooks Online sync starts on Core. Go stops at the first 10 payments. Ramp Free includes QuickBooks Online. Tipalti lists QuickBooks among its integrations and says a custom integration may cost extra. |
| Payment | Standard ACH from a bank account for the accepted portion only. | BILL lists $0.59 for ACH funded from a bank, BILL Balance or BILL Cash Account. Melio lists partial payments and $0.50 ACH after the plan allowance. Ramp lists $0.59 standard ACH from an external bank. Tipalti and Stampli name ACH and do not print the fee. |
BILL Corporate also lists a discount for approver-only users. The page does not print that discounted rate, so the price below treats all three people as full users.
Ramp's compare table also lists three-way match against imported purchase orders and item receipts. The plan marks on that row are icons, so this worksheet does not assign that row to Free.
One steady month of users and payments
Modeled steady month, not a live invoice and not the first-90-days promotion: 3 full users, 1 US entity, QuickBooks Online, 40 standard domestic ACH payments, 4 standard mailed checks, and 1 international payment in US dollars. No card funding, same-day ACH, or overnight checks. Rates were read on November 19, 2026. Figures are US dollars before tax.
| Line | BILL Team | BILL Corporate | Melio Core, monthly | Ramp Free, external bank |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Software | $195.00 | $267.00 | $45.00 | $0.00 |
| Domestic ACH | $23.60 | $23.60 | $10.00 | $23.60 |
| Mailed checks | $7.96 | $7.96 | $6.00 | $7.96 |
| International USD | $19.99 wire | $19.99 wire | $20.00 global ACH | $20.00 SWIFT |
| Modeled month | $246.55 | $318.55 | $81.00 | $51.56 |
BILL is 3 users times $65 on Team or $89 on Corporate. ACH is 40 times $0.59. Checks are 4 times $1.99. The international line is one $19.99 USD wire, and BILL says that fee may be transferred to the receiver. Team buys the QuickBooks Online sync and standard approval policies. It does not buy custom approval policies or included 2-way matching. Corporate does. Neither row buys priced 3-way matching. The page shows a per-user monthly amount and no separate annual rate.
Melio Core is $25 plus $10 for each of 2 additional users. Twenty of the 40 ACH payments are inside the allowance, so 20 times $0.50 is $10. Checks are 4 times $1.50. The international line is Melio's $20 flat fee for a global ACH paid in US dollars, which is a different rail from BILL's wire and Ramp's SWIFT transfer. Core covers the approval routes and QuickBooks Online sync. It does not cover a published receipt match, so $81 does not buy the short-receipt step.
Ramp Free software is $0. A new account in this model pays 40 times $0.59 ACH, 4 times $1.99 checks, and one $20 SWIFT USD transfer. The June 1, 2026 ACH and check fees had a three-month grace period for customers who had already paid a bill before May 1, 2026. This model does not use that grace period. Paying the same three methods from a Ramp Checking Account waives those fees, so the modeled Ramp month is $0 before any other Ramp product. Overnight checks and check attachments are not waived.
The annual Melio Core equivalents on the same page are $20 for the plan and $8 per extra user. That changes the software line from $45 to $36 and the modeled month from $81 to $72. The payment fees are unchanged. BILL Spend and Expense is a separate $0 per user product and is not in these totals.
Fees left out of the modeled totals
Pages that only show a starting price or a feature list do not price this month. These items stay out of the $246.55, $318.55, $81.00 and $51.56 totals.
| Boundary | Published term | Do not invent |
|---|---|---|
| Tipalti Accounts Payable | Plans start at $99 per month, with unlimited users, no per-user or per-approver fee, and standard implementation included. | The per-invoice fee, the per-payment fee, FX, added entities, and the Procurement, Expenses and Treasury modules. Complex setups may require paid services. Mid-market pricing is a custom quote. |
| Stampli | The pricing page offers a quote. It lists invoice capture, 2-way and 3-way matching, domestic check and ACH, and global ACH and wire. | Any platform price or payment fee. Nothing on the page turns the modeled month into a number. |
| BILL Enterprise and add-ons | Enterprise is custom pricing. It is the plan that lists purchase-order sync and automatic 2-way and 3-way matching. Procurement is an add-on on Essentials and Team. | The 3-way match price for QuickBooks Online, the procurement add-on price, and the approver-only discount. |
| Ramp Plus | $15 per user per month, and the page says save 20% with annual billing. Three users are $45, or $36 if that discount applies only to the published seat price. | The platform fee based on team size, and the price of the Procurement add-on that carries Ramp's own three-way match. |
| Melio introductory offer | The first 90 days can be $0 with unlimited free ACH. Without a paid plan after that, the account becomes Go and premium-feature data is deleted. | Using $0 or the one-user Go plan as the steady price for 3 users and 40 ACH payments. |
Tipalti's $99 is a platform floor. The pricing FAQ says the monthly price also depends on payments, legal entities, modules, and payment methods, and that payment fees vary by method and destination without listing the amounts.
Essentials at 3 times $49 would show a lower software line and still leave QuickBooks Online on CSV. It is the wrong plan for the sync this worksheet requires.
Sandbox steps for that invoice
This trial has not been run. Use one sandbox company and the same invoice, receipt and users. Record the plan name on the quote next to each result.
| Trial step | Record | Pass condition |
|---|---|---|
| Short receipt | Purchase order for 10, receipt for 6, invoice for 10 at $4,200. | The held 4 units stay unpaid, with the receipt attached, until a second approval. |
| Approval authority | Require the department owner for this vendor and try the payment as another user. | The other user cannot release it, and that route is included in the named plan rather than an unpriced add-on. |
| QuickBooks Online | Compare the bill, the held amount and the payment with the ledger. | The books show the held amount and the paid amount separately, without a second manual entry. |
| ACH fee | Pay the accepted portion by standard ACH from the bank or account named in the model. | The fee on the statement matches the row used: $0.59, $0.50 after Melio's allowance, or $0 from a Ramp Checking Account. |
| Quote-only vendors | Ask Tipalti and Stampli to price these exact counts, including implementation. | The quote prices 40 ACH payments, 4 checks, 1 USD international payment and the short-receipt route, with services listed apart from the platform fee. |
Do not treat a successful OCR demo as a pass. The pass condition is the exception, the named approver, the ledger and the fee together.
Sources
- BILL Accounts Payable plans, sync, approvals and payor fees
- Melio plans, QuickBooks sync, approvals and transaction fees
- Ramp Free, Plus and Enterprise plan features
- Ramp Bill Pay methods, fees and Checking Account waivers
- Tipalti Accounts Payable starting price and unpublished transaction fees
- Stampli pricing page, quote only